Microsoft 365 holds a lot of what a small business runs on: email, files, calendars, Teams chats and often the sign-in for other apps as well. Out of the box it comes with sensible protections, but many tenants were set up years ago, added to in a hurry and never reviewed. A few settings left in the wrong place can turn one stolen password into a much bigger problem.
Here are ten settings worth checking in your Microsoft 365 tenant. You don't need to be an expert to work through them, but you will need a Global Administrator account, and it's a good idea to make changes during a quiet time and tell staff what to expect. Each item links to Microsoft's own documentation so you can see exactly where the setting lives.
1. Make sure every account uses multi-factor authentication
Multi-factor authentication (MFA) is the single most useful protection for Microsoft 365. For most small businesses the simplest way to switch it on is security defaults, which require MFA registration for everyone and block older sign-in methods that can't do MFA. If you have Microsoft 365 Business Premium, Conditional Access policies give you finer control instead.
Check that nobody has been quietly left out, such as the owner, a shared login used by reception or an account created for a contractor. Where you can, steer people towards the Microsoft Authenticator app or passkeys rather than text message codes. We covered why in our post on Microsoft retiring SMS sign-in codes.
2. Keep Global Administrators to a small, named group
A Global Administrator can change anything in your tenant, so each of those accounts is a high-value target. In its role best-practice guidance, Microsoft recommends assigning the Global Administrator role to fewer than five people.
- Review who holds admin roles in the Microsoft 365 admin centre under Roles.
- Give people the narrowest role that does the job, for example User Administrator or Exchange Administrator.
- Use a separate admin account for admin work, rather than the account people use for everyday email and browsing.
3. Set up an emergency access account
If your only admin is locked out, or an MFA change goes wrong, you can lose control of your own tenant. Microsoft suggests keeping emergency access accounts, sometimes called break-glass accounts, that are protected with strong, phishing-resistant authentication, stored securely and used only when something has gone wrong. Write down where the details are kept and who is allowed to use them.
4. Check your Secure Score
Microsoft Secure Score in the Microsoft Defender portal looks at your tenant and lists recommended improvements, ranked by impact. It's a useful to-do list rather than a pass or fail mark. Don't chase a perfect number; instead, read the top recommendations, decide which make sense for your business and mark the rest as accepted risks with a short note on why.
5. Turn on preset email protection policies
Email is still the most common way phishing and malware arrive. Microsoft Defender includes preset security policies called Standard and Strict, which apply Microsoft's recommended anti-spam, anti-malware and anti-phishing settings in one go. If you've never touched these settings, applying the Standard preset to all users is a reasonable starting point. If your plan includes Defender for Office 365, the presets also cover Safe Links and Safe Attachments.
6. Block automatic forwarding to outside addresses
A common trick after someone's mailbox is compromised is to add a rule that silently forwards their email to an outside address. The attacker then reads invoices and conversations and waits for the right moment to send a fake payment request. Microsoft lets you control external email forwarding through the outbound spam policy.
- Confirm automatic forwarding to external addresses is blocked, and allow it only for specific people who genuinely need it.
- Look through existing mailbox rules for anything forwarding mail outside the business.
7. Stop staff approving risky apps on their own
Some phishing attacks don't ask for a password at all. Instead they ask the person to approve an app that then gets access to their mailbox or files. Review the user consent settings in Microsoft Entra ID so staff can only approve low-risk permissions from verified publishers, or none at all, with an admin approving anything else. While you're there, look at the list of apps that already have access and remove any you don't recognise.
8. Review SharePoint and OneDrive sharing
Easy sharing is one of the best parts of Microsoft 365, but "anyone with the link" links can travel further than intended. Check your external sharing settings and choose a level that suits how you actually work.
- Consider limiting sharing to people who sign in, rather than anonymous links.
- If you do allow anyone links, set them to expire after a set number of days.
- Make the default link type "people in your organisation" so outside sharing is a deliberate choice.
9. Make sure audit logging is on
If something does go wrong, the audit log is how you find out what happened: who signed in, which files were accessed and which rules were created. Microsoft explains how to confirm auditing is turned on in the Microsoft Purview portal. It only takes a minute to check, and it's far better to know now than to discover there's no record during an incident.
10. Set up self-service password reset and email authentication
Two smaller settings round out the list. Self-service password reset lets staff reset a forgotten password after proving who they are, which saves time and reduces the risk of someone being talked into resetting a password over the phone. And for your own domain, make sure DKIM signing is enabled alongside SPF and DMARC records, which makes it harder for others to send email that looks like it came from you.
Where Australian guidance fits in
The Australian Signals Directorate publishes the Blueprint for Secure Cloud, which includes detailed configuration guidance for Microsoft 365, and the ACSC's cyber.gov.au has plain-English advice for small businesses. The blueprint is written with larger organisations in mind, so treat it as a reference rather than a checklist you must complete. The ten settings above cover the areas that matter most for a typical small team.
Make it a regular habit
Settings drift over time. New staff join, someone gets admin rights "just for today", a supplier needs a shared folder and Microsoft adds new features. Put a reminder in your calendar to run through this list every quarter, and keep a short record of what you checked and anything you changed. That record is also handy if you're ever asked about your security by an insurer or a larger customer.
How MSP Logic can help
If you'd rather not dig through admin portals yourself, we can review your tenant against these settings, explain what we find in plain English and fix the gaps with minimal disruption to your team. Read more about our Microsoft 365 support and cybersecurity services, or get in touch to arrange a review.